Selling the farm

Rising health insurance costs burden farm, ranch families

By Jeff Bunn
Capital Journal staff
Published/Last Modified on Thursday, Dec 27, 2007 - 06:05:34 am CST

PIERRE — Dale Brehe’s private insurance plight as a farmer is not unusual.

In fact, his $375.75 premium and $2,500 deductible and his wife’s $352.89 premium and $5,000 deductible are what many farm and ranch families pay, according to a recent study by Access Project, a research group that looks at health care costs.

“They keep saying, ‘It’s rising health care costs and hospital costs,’” Brehe said of his health insurance carrier. “The deductibles are ridiculous. You just carry the insurance for the catastrophic stuff so you don’t loose the farm.”

Jeff Bunn | Capital Journal
Dale Brehe works with some of his calves last Thursday. Like many farm and ranch families, Brehe pays nearly $1,000 dollars in health insurance premiums and a $5,000 and $2,500 deductible.
Advertisement

Born to a farming and ranching family with land near Agar, Brehe, now strictly livestock, said his father carried private insurance. But things were different then.

“He got to be 65 when I was 25,” Brehe said. “So, he had supplement insurance, and he had long-term health insurance. But it’s pretty unreal what they want for that.”

Recalling the family’s insurance policies from 1976 when he married his wife, Jane, to the time their daughter graduated high school to the present, Brehe said the family has gone through separate policies and dealt with insurance companies that have come and gone from the state.

“We had health insurance as a family,” Brehe said. “It was costing between four and $500 a month, and it only had a $500 deductible. It didn’t go out of reason for a while. The legislature passed a law sometime in the late ’80s that made most insurance companies pull out of the state.

The one we had when they pulled out sold their subscribers to this other company so they just transferred us over.

“The other insurance companies wouldn’t even talk to us. It was only three years until that insurance company pulled out of the state. They gave us six months notice and they said, ‘You’re on your own.’ I went two years without insurance.”

Though Brehe said private health insurance is part of farming, Nancy Cohen, who helped survey the 2,000 farmers in seven Great Plains states for Access Project’s report, said she is constantly surprised by farmers’ and ranchers’ private health-care burdens.

“I talked to rancher in Harrold who has a $1,400 premium and $5,000 deductible,” Cohen said. “I ask myself, ‘How long can you do that?’”

After shoulder surgery and a broken pelvis claimed on off-the-farm employment insurance, Brehe was unable to get WellMark Insurance, which is sold through the farm bureau.

Taking a construction job at Sutton Bay Golf Course and a two-year stint at Wal-Mart alleviated the pressure of paying high premiums and deductibles, though the family kept their private insurance, Brehe said.

“When I was working off the farm, the farm still was taken care of,” Brehe said. “It was just taking more hours. I would get off work at 5, and then farm. During haying season, I’d work until I couldn’t see anymore.”

After his wife had knee-replacement surgery for both knees this past year, the insurance pressures came into sharper focus, Brehe said.

“If we didn’t have insurance and she had to have her knees done, we’d lose the farm,” Brehe said. “If you can keep paying the premium, at least, you save your livelihood.”

Michael Held, CEO of South Dakota Farm Bureau, said health insurance for farmers and ranchers has been a concern for the bureau for many years.

“We hear reports of members paying $10,000 to $12,000 a year for health insurance policy,” Held said. “It’s been increasing on a steady rise for a long time. There have been years where premiums have risen 12 to 15 percent.”

Pooling its 4,000 policy holders, including Medicare supplement holders, to negotiate with WellMark for relatively set premium prices, South Dakota Farm Bureau would like to go beyond state lines to build a larger base to avoid the dramatic premium price jumps, Held said.

“We think one option would be to let associations pull their members across state lines,” Held said. “It is not do-able right now. But, you would get a bigger group of individuals in a pool. In a low-population state like South Dakota, that’s a challenge, and if you could put some states together and pool your resources, you have better buying power.”

Not advocating a national health care plan, Bill Lottero, co-author of the Access Project’s report, said researchers believe there are things that can be done to control premium increases.

“The gorilla in the room is private insurance companies,” Lottero said. “They need to be transparent about costs. And it’s not just Farm Bureau who can take them to task, policymakers have to start asking these questions

“We think private and public partnership, in which the government and the private industry come together to craft effective partnership, can contain costs and offer quality products at a reasonable prices. The country was built on small businesses, and we need to provide some support for them.”

Print this story Post A Comment

WARNING:

• Comments are not verified for accuracy nor have we verified the identity of any person’s name accompanying a comment, so please consider this as you weigh any statements made or opinions offered.

NOTE:

• Comments will not be posted if submitted in all caps, or all lower case, or do not show a reasonable attempt to follow basic rules of grammar and punctuation, nor will text-message like abbreviations be accepted, like ur for your.
• Postings must stay on the issues related to the thread and not veer off into personal comments about others. The tone of the post must be civil. For example, you can say someone’s ideas are stupid but you cannot say another poster is stupid.
• Postings must deal with matters of public concern.

Comments

11 comment(s)

still breathing wrote on Jan 1, 2008 9:26 PM:

" I haven't had health insurance since 1996, at that time my then wife had a reasonable family plan through her employer. I am now a single parent and it is practically impossible to afford health insurance. Fortunately I'm spiritually well and rarely get sick. I shake my head and just wish health care insurance were in reach, we're all in a very precarious place here. "

Public Voice wrote on Dec 31, 2007 7:18 PM:

" Everyone has health care needs and unfortunately the cost of that service is high (tort lawyers, malpractice, government regulation,....). I guess the Capital Journal may want to expand their coverage of this issue to include all self employeed people who pay for high priced insurance policies without the benefit of USDA payments ($18K for the person who their story portrays - per the EWG.org database) "

James wrote on Dec 31, 2007 10:26 AM:

" A lot of folks go to Rapid City and Sioux Falls for resonable/competant health care. "

421412525 wrote on Dec 30, 2007 11:47 PM:

" There is a hidden culprit in all of this. That is the ever rising cost of health care. The insurance companies just pass that along. If we are really interested in lowering insurance costs, we need to shut down the double digit inflation in health care costs. Our local hospital is much more expensive than comparable coverage in other facilities. Insurance or not, when you have to pay as much out of pocket as the total bill elsewhere, it doesn't matter who pays your insurance!! "

Double Dipper wrote on Dec 29, 2007 7:09 PM:

" I'm sure his large Crop Disaster check will cover his health insurance and still provide enough for a new set of Carharts. "

r wrote on Dec 28, 2007 1:03 PM:

" I used to work for the state and then switched to a private corporation. State benefits are outstanding, whether you want to make yourself sound beleagured or not LC. The job I had with the state was awful, which is the reason I was willing to give up the benefits, state employees have some of the best health care, hands down. It's not an attack against state employees. It's a fact. "

Together wrote on Dec 28, 2007 11:06 AM:

" We are all in this together. Don't knock one profession over another. It is "us" against the high cost of the health industry! $25.00 for an aspirin? WHOA! "

LC wrote on Dec 28, 2007 9:42 AM:

" Why does everyone always knock the State Employees? First it is money and now it is insurance. A State Job is not "rosy" as all of you think. Get a job for the State then and quick griping. Then you can be a State Employee too!!! "

db wrote on Dec 27, 2007 4:58 PM:

" Even govt insurance bites a chunk out of the paycheck we do both govt and farm and try to avoid going to the doctors due to the high deductible annually and the co-pays. The large private sector is the only inexpensive insurance and co-pays for anyone. So don't be disillusioned by the great benefits of govt employment, it's not all that... "

Steven wrote on Dec 27, 2007 11:15 AM:

" It is not just farmers and ranchers. It is anyone who owns and or works for a small business. That is why working for the government or a large buisness (Wal Mart) is becoming so appealing. "

On the same boat wrote on Dec 27, 2007 8:50 AM:

" I'm a small business owner and have a high deductible and a high premium. Those people who have jobs that pay for most of their insurance (goverment) dont know how well they have it. "

WRITE A COMMENT

Use the form below to post a brief comment to this story, or respond to other readers. Please use the word count tool to assist you in keeping your remarks to 100 words or fewer.

Comments must be approved by an editor before appearing on the Web site. Editors review submitted comments periodically during the day for offensive or off-topic content before posting. Your thoughtful contribution to the online discussion is appreciated.